Amalgam vs. White Fillings: Which Is Right for You?

emergency dental fillings Brisbane - composite filling

Best Dental Filling In Fortitute Valley & Brisbane


Dental fillings play a crucial role in preserving our oral health, offering a solution to a common dental woe: cavities. These tiny restorations are like unsung heroes, quietly safeguarding our teeth from further decay and discomfort. However, when it comes to dental fillings, it’s important to recognize that not all fillings are created equal.

In this blog post, we will delve into the world of dental fillings and shed light on two primary contenders: amalgam and white fillings. Our mission here at Amitis Dental Studio in Fortitude Valley, QLD, is to empower you with knowledge, enabling you to make informed decisions about your dental health.

So, let’s embark on this journey together as we explore the differences between these two types of fillings, ultimately guiding you towards the choice that’s right for you.

What are Amalgam Fillings?

Amalgam fillings, often referred to as silver fillings, are a time-tested and widely used dental restoration option. They have been in use for over a century, and their composition plays a significant role in their durability and functionality.

Amalgam fillings Brisbane

Advantages of Amalgam Fillings:

  • Durability: Amalgam fillings are known for their exceptional durability and longevity. They can withstand the pressures of chewing and can last for many years, often exceeding other filling materials.
  • Cost-effectiveness: Amalgam fillings are generally more affordable compared to alternative options, making them a practical choice for individuals seeking cost-effective dental restorations.

Concerns and Controversies:

  • Mercury Content: One of the most significant concerns surrounding amalgam fillings is their mercury content. While the mercury in amalgam fillings is chemically bound to the other metals and considered safe for most individuals, some people worry about potential mercury exposure. It’s important to note that numerous scientific studies have found that amalgam fillings pose minimal health risks.
  • Aesthetics: Another aspect that can be considered a drawback is the aesthetics. Amalgam fillings have a silver-grey colour, which can be quite noticeable in the mouth. This may be a concern for individuals who prioritize a more natural appearance in their dental work.

What Are White Fillings (Composite Resin)?

White fillings, also known as composite resin fillings, represent a modern and aesthetically pleasing alternative to traditional amalgam fillings. They have gained popularity due to their ability to seamlessly blend with the natural colour of your teeth, making them virtually unnoticeable.

Tooth-Coloured Appearance:

White fillings, also known as composite resin fillings, represent a modern and aesthetically pleasing alternative to traditional amalgam fillings. They have gained popularity due to their ability to seamlessly blend with the natural colour of your teeth, making them virtually unnoticeable.

Benefits of White Fillings:

1 – Natural Look: The primary advantage of white fillings is their ability to match the colour of your teeth. This aesthetic advantage makes them an ideal choice for visible areas, such as the front teeth, where a natural appearance is of utmost importance.

2 – Bonding with the Tooth: White fillings bond directly to the tooth structure. This means that less healthy tooth structure needs to be removed during the filling procedure compared to amalgam fillings. This preservation of natural tooth structure is a significant benefit.

3 – Reduced Sensitivity: White fillings are less sensitive to temperature changes than metal fillings, which can be beneficial for individuals with sensitive teeth.

4 – Versatile Applications: Composite resin is a versatile material that can be used for various dental procedures beyond fillings, such as repairing chips, cracks, or gaps in teeth, and even for cosmetic enhancements like veneers and bonding.

Drawbacks or Limitations of White Fillings:

  • Cost: One of the primary drawbacks of white fillings is their cost. They tend to be more expensive than traditional amalgam fillings, primarily due to the materials used and the technique required for placement.
  • Longevity: While white fillings have improved in terms of durability over the years, they may not last as long as amalgam fillings. Their longevity can be affected by factors such as their size, location in the mouth, and the patient’s oral hygiene practices.
  • Staining: Over time, white fillings may become more susceptible to staining from food, beverages, and smoking. Regular maintenance and proper oral hygiene are essential to preserve their appearance.


Dental Fillings Amitis Dental Studio - Tooth coloured dental fillings

What Factors Should You Consider?

Imagine smiling with confidence. White fillings, with their tooth-coloured appearance, grant you this freedom. They seamlessly blend with your natural teeth, erasing any self-consciousness about visible dental work. Whether you’re laughing with friends or presenting in a business meeting, your smile remains radiant and unblemished.

1. Aesthetics

White fillings, also known as composite resin fillings, represent a modern and aesthetically pleasing alternative to traditional amalgam fillings. They have gained popularity due to their ability to seamlessly blend with the natural colour of your teeth, making them virtually unnoticeable.

2. Durability:

Picture a worry-free future. Amalgam fillings boast exceptional durability, capable of withstanding the rigours of daily chewing and biting. This longevity means fewer trips to the dentist and more years of uninterrupted enjoyment.

3. Cost:

Invest in your health and happiness. While white fillings may come with a higher price tag, they represent an investment in both your oral health and self-esteem. Consider it a long-term commitment to preserving your natural smile and well-being.

4. Allergies or Sensitivities:

Prioritize your comfort. If you have concerns about allergies or sensitivities to certain materials, discuss them openly with your dentist. They can assess your unique situation and recommend the safest and most suitable option for your specific needs.

5. Location and Size of the Filling:

Tailored solutions for your unique case. The placement and size of the filling matter. For visible areas and smaller fillings, white fillings excel at providing discreet and effective solutions. For larger fillings in non-visible areas, durability may take precedence.

Personalized Recommendations

Now that we’ve explored the essential factors in the decision-making process between amalgam and white fillings, it’s crucial to understand that this choice is profoundly personal. No one-size-fits-all solution exists because your unique needs and circumstances shape the ideal choice for your dental health journey.

Highly Individual Choice:

Your dental needs, expectations, and priorities are distinct. Are you seeking a natural, aesthetically pleasing result for a visible tooth? Are you prioritizing long-term durability or immediate cost-effectiveness?

Do you have specific concerns like allergies or sensitivities? The answers to these questions can vary greatly from one person to another, highlighting the highly individual nature of this decision.

Consult with Our Dentist:

To navigate this decision effectively, we strongly recommend scheduling a consultation with our experienced dentists at Amitis Dental Studio in Fortitude Valley, Brisbane. Our dedicated professionals are here to listen to your concerns, assess your oral health condition, and fully understand your preferences.

A Tailored Solution for You:

By seeking personalized guidance, you’ll embark on a path toward a solution uniquely tailored to your needs. Your dentist will take into account all the factors we’ve discussed, as well as any additional considerations specific to your case.

This collaborative approach ensures that the choice between amalgam and white fillings aligns seamlessly with your vision for optimal dental health and a radiant smile.

Remember, at Amitis Dental Studio, your satisfaction and well-being are our top priorities. We’re here to guide you every step of the way, providing the expertise and care needed to make the best decision for your individual circumstances.

Together, we’ll create a personalized plan that not only addresses your immediate dental needs but also supports your long-term oral health and confidence.

Aftercare and Maintenance

Congratulations on your choice of dental fillings! To ensure their longevity and effectiveness, it’s essential to adopt a diligent aftercare and maintenance routine. Whether you’ve opted for amalgam or white fillings, these tips will help you maintain a healthy and beautiful smile.

1. Proper Oral Hygiene:

Amalgam Fillings: Amalgam fillings are sturdy, but maintaining good oral hygiene remains crucial. Brush your teeth twice daily with fluoride toothpaste and use dental floss to clean between your teeth. Regular brushing and flossing help prevent cavities and gum disease.

White Fillings: White fillings bond directly to your tooth’s surface, making it important to be gentle during your oral hygiene routine. Use a soft-bristle toothbrush to avoid abrasive wear. Continue to brush and floss regularly to prevent staining and maintain the integrity of the filling.

dentist explains dental check up and clean process

2. Dietary Considerations:

Amalgam Fillings: You can maintain your regular diet with amalgam fillings. However, consider reducing your consumption of sugary and acidic foods and beverages, as these can contribute to tooth decay over time.

White Fillings: While white fillings are stain-resistant, they may still be susceptible to discolouration over time. Limit consumption of staining agents such as coffee, tea, red wine, and tobacco to preserve their appearance. Additionally, avoid biting into hard objects like ice or nuts, as this can chip or damage the composite material.

3. Regular Dental Check-ups:

Regardless of the type of filling you have, regular dental check-ups are essential. Our dentist will monitor the condition of your fillings, assess your oral health, and address any concerns promptly. These check-ups help identify potential issues before they become major problems, ensuring the longevity of your dental work.

4. Address Sensitivity or Discomfort:

If you experience any sensitivity or discomfort around your filling, don’t hesitate to contact your dentist. Sensitivity can occur temporarily after a filling procedure, but if it persists, it may indicate an issue that needs attention.

By following these aftercare and maintenance guidelines, you’ll be well on your way to preserving the longevity and effectiveness of your dental fillings. Remember that our team at Amitis Dental Studio in Fortitude Valley, QLD, is here to support you in maintaining a healthy and beautiful smile.

Regular check-ups and open communication with your dentist are key to ensuring your dental fillings continue to serve you well for years to come.

Common Myths and Misconceptions About Dental Fillings

1. Fillings Last Forever:

Myth: Some people believe that once they get a dental filling, it will last a lifetime without any need for maintenance or replacement.

Reality: Dental fillings have a lifespan, and their durability depends on various factors, including the type of filling material used, oral hygiene, and the location of the filling in the mouth. Over time, fillings may wear down, crack, or become loose, necessitating replacement.

2. All Fillings Are Silver (Amalgam):

Myth: Many people think that all dental fillings are silver or amalgam fillings.

Reality: While amalgam fillings are one type of dental filling, there are also tooth-coloured options like composite resin fillings. These white fillings are designed to match the natural colour of your teeth, making them virtually invisible.

3. Dental Fillings Cause Toothaches:

Myth: Some individuals believe that getting a dental filling will lead to toothaches or increased sensitivity.

Reality: Dental fillings are typically used to treat toothaches and sensitivity caused by cavities or dental decay. They remove the damaged portion of the tooth and restore it, relieving discomfort.

4. Dental Fillings Are Only for Cavities:

Myth: People often assume that dental fillings are solely used to treat cavities.

Reality: While fillings are commonly used for cavities, they can also be employed to repair chipped, cracked, or broken teeth and to fill gaps or spaces between teeth. Dentists use fillings for various restorative and cosmetic purposes.

5. You Can't Eat Normally After Getting a Filling:

Myth: Some individuals think that they have to avoid certain foods or alter their eating habits drastically after getting a dental filling.

Reality: After a dental filling, you can typically resume your regular eating habits once any anesthesia has worn off. However, it’s advisable to avoid extremely hot or cold foods immediately afterwards if you experience any temporary sensitivity.

6. Allergies to Filling Materials are Common:

Myth: There’s a misconception that many people are allergic to the materials used in dental fillings.

Reality: Allergies to dental filling materials are quite rare. The materials used, such as amalgam or composite resin, are generally well-tolerated by most patients. However, if you have concerns about allergies, you can discuss them with your dentist.

7. Dental Fillings Weaken Teeth:

Myth: Some people believe that getting a dental filling weakens the tooth.

Reality: Dental fillings are designed to restore the strength and function of a damaged tooth. They remove the decayed or damaged portion and reinforce the tooth’s structure, helping to prevent further deterioration.


In the journey to safeguard your dental health and enhance your smile, the choice between amalgam and white fillings emerges as a pivotal decision. Let’s recap the essential points we’ve explored in this blog post:

Amalgam Fillings offer exceptional durability and cost-effectiveness, making them a reliable choice for many. Concerns about mercury content and their silver appearance should be considered.

White Fillings (Composite Resin) provides a natural, tooth-coloured aesthetic, bonding seamlessly with your teeth. They are versatile, comfortable, and, above all, discreet. However, factors like cost and longevity require careful consideration.

Ultimately, the choice between these two options is highly individual, influenced by factors such as aesthetics, durability, cost, sensitivities, and the location and size of the filling. Your unique needs and preferences should guide your decision.

Your smile is a precious asset, and your dental health deserves the best care. If you’ve found yourself contemplating the choice between amalgam and white fillings or have any dental concerns whatsoever, we invite you to take action today.

Contact Amitis Dental Studio

Our team of dedicated professionals at Amitis Dental Studio in Brisbane, QLD, is here to guide you towards optimal dental health and a confident smile. Whether you seek a personalized recommendation, have questions, or require assistance with any dental concern, we’re just a call away.

What Is Next?

Don’t delay your journey to a radiant smile and optimal dental well-being. Contact Amitis Dental Studio today, and let us be your partners in achieving the confident and beautiful smile you deserve.

Your health and happiness are our top priorities, and we look forward to welcoming you to our clinic. Call (07)  4194 2525 today to book an appointment.